Black and Blue (Oprah’s Book Club)

A good read February 8, 2009
Teacher’s Pet (Lockport, New York)
This is well written and not as predictable as one would think. If you have ever lived in a dysfunctional relationship with fear, you will appreciate this one.

Parts excellent, others less so July 20, 2008
An Anonymous Child
As an occasional reader of Anna Quindlen’s column (who often disagrees or doesn’t quite like what’s written), it’s hard to disagree with the fact that Quindlen is an excellent writer and has an intelligent mind. This was the first novel of hers that I read, and I’ll probably seek out more.

But I didn’t really love the book. I liked a lot of it, that’s true. But some parts bothered me quite a bit. The writing is really great – you’re immersed into this world wholly and feel like characters around you are warm and alive. From son Robert to neighbor Cindy, there’s this vivid and clear world. The story runs on a perfectly smooth track, alternating rather well (I felt) between past and present.

Meanwhile, I didn’t really like the end. I didn’t like the rather stereotypical situation with the husband and the husband’s character (abusive, possessive cop… overdone perhaps?). The description of abuse was laid on rather well but felt used and kind of dry. I thought main character Fran/Beth could have been drawn better. And most of all, I felt some parts of the book were a bit far-fetched.

I really liked the book until the very ending where, though it touched my heart, I felt a bit empty. Perhaps this was the intention, but with other far-fetched moments throughout the book it added up to being simply a four-star book – well-written, much better than most, but still lacking in some places. I enjoyed reading it all the way through and comparatively, it’s a high four or a four-and-a-half, but some parts were definitely weaker.

Good side-character characterization, excellent writing, extremely difficult and important topic, and very good presentation means that this book is fairly good. While it’s not a classic, it’s a deep and significant read that I would recommend and one that will lead me to seek out more of Quindlen’s novels.

Boring, long winded and pathetically predictable May 29, 2008
Lady Liberty (USA)
2 out of 2 found this review helpful

The title of my review sums it up. Quindlen went all over the map, describing people, emotions and scenarios that were empty. I skipped dozens of pages of yawn-infused diatribe to get to something…anything…that would be interesting. The ending was so predictable it was laughable and an insult to her readers. Not her best effort.

Blue on Black, a whisper on a shout February 22, 2008
Minna Minocha (Iowa, USA)
Anna Quindlen can really write well, and I enjoyed this book a lot. It’s the story of one woman’s daring escape after years of domestic abuse. Unfortunately, this tale has been told a couple dozen times in the last few years, but Quindlen works hard to make it feel fresh.

The characters are the best part of Quindlen’s writing. Their emotions seem real, which is the hallmark of good writing. My book club agreed that this is one of the best books that we’ve read recently, like Rabid: A Novel by T.K. Kenyon and The Handmaid’s Tale (Everyman’s Library) by Margeret Atwood.

Minna

Just okay. February 22, 2008
Robin Wermuth (Chicago, IL)
I was never really captivated by this book until page 170 or so. That’s about when the story really got moving. There was a lot of switching back and forth between memories and present, and the transitions weren’t clear. So, I was often confused. In my opinion, the book was just okay. Nothing overly exciting, never got really attached to the characters.